If your phone supports eSIM and is unlocked, a travel eSIM is usually the simplest choice: you buy and install it before you leave and keep your home SIM in place. A local SIM card suits people who need a local phone number or a long stay, or whose phone cannot take an eSIM. A rented pocket Wi-Fi device suits groups who stay together and devices that cannot take a SIM at all, such as Wi-Fi-only tablets. Each has a case where it is the best answer.
All Things eSIM earns a commission when you buy travel eSIMs through some links on this site. We do not earn from local SIMs or pocket Wi-Fi rentals, and this guide does not assume a travel eSIM is right for you.
Start with compatibility, lock and local-number needs
Three questions rule options out before cost comes into it:
- Does your phone support eSIM? If not, a travel eSIM is not an option. Check with our compatibility checker.
- Is your phone locked to your home network? A locked phone cannot use another provider's SIM or eSIM. On iPhone, Settings > General > About shows "No SIM restrictions" next to Carrier Lock if it is unlocked. A pocket Wi-Fi works with a locked phone, because the phone only joins its Wi-Fi.
- Do you need a local phone number? Most travel eSIMs are data only. A local SIM from a local network is the usual way to get a local number.
The three methods compared
Travel eSIM | Local SIM or eSIM from a local network | Pocket Wi-Fi rental | |
|---|---|---|---|
Phone must support eSIM | Yes | Only for a local eSIM | No |
Phone must be unlocked | Yes | Yes | No |
Works for Wi-Fi-only devices | Only through your phone's hotspot | Only through your phone's hotspot | Yes |
Independent use when people split up | Yes, each phone with a plan | Yes, each phone with a SIM | Only for whoever carries the device |
Local phone number | Rarely | Often | No |
Set up before departure | Yes | Sometimes (some sell online); often at the airport or a shop | Order online; collect on arrival or delivered to accommodation |
Hardware to collect and return | None | A SIM card (none for a local eSIM) | A device, charger and envelope to return |
Identity checks | Product-dependent; often none for data-only | Often required by local rules | Usually a booking; check the rental terms |
Your home SIM stays in the phone | Yes | Only if your phone has room for both | Yes |
Extra charges to look for | Top-ups; fair use limits | Top-ups; local plan terms | Late return, lost device, lost accessories |
Solo, couple and shared-device scenarios
These are hypothetical trips to Japan, used only to show how the methods differ.
- Solo traveller, unlocked phone that supports eSIM, two weeks. A travel eSIM installed at home. No pickup, no return, home SIM stays in for bank texts.
- Couple who split up during the day. Two travel eSIMs, one each, or two local SIMs if both phones are unlocked. A single pocket Wi-Fi leaves whoever does not carry it offline.
- Family with a Wi-Fi-only tablet and one locked phone. A pocket Wi-Fi covers both the tablet and the locked phone. The adults with unlocked phones may still want their own travel eSIMs for when they are apart.
- Six-week stay with a local number needed. A local SIM or eSIM from a Japanese network, if you can meet its sign-up rules.
Pickup, returns, charging and deposits
A rental device is another thing to collect, charge and return. Japan Wireless, one Japanese rental company, says on its own site that it delivers across Japan, has pickup counters at seven airports, includes a prepaid return envelope and asks for the device to be dropped in any Japanese postbox by 3pm the day after the rental ends, with late returns charged. Other rental companies set their own rules on deposits, lost-device charges and returns. Read them before booking.
Also think about:
- Battery. The device runs on its own battery, so carry a power bank.
- Range. Everyone using it needs to stay nearby.
- Return logistics. Missing the return deadline at the airport can add charges.
Registration and activation differences
- Travel eSIM: installed from a QR code or app, often before you leave. Many data-only products ask for no ID, but some do; see our ID requirements guide. Validity often starts on first connection in the destination.
- Local SIM or eSIM: Apple notes that buying from a local carrier may require ID such as a passport, and postpaid plans may need proof of residency, a local bank account or a credit card. Rules vary by country and network.
- Pocket Wi-Fi: booked online with a rental period; the device is ready to use when you collect it.
Not every country requires ID for a physical SIM, and not every rental is more expensive than an eSIM. Check the specific products for your trip.
Choose by constraints, not a universal winner
If this applies | Lean towards |
|---|---|
Unlocked, eSIM-capable phone; want setup done before you fly | Travel eSIM |
Need a local number, or staying a long time in one country | Local SIM or eSIM |
Phone is locked or does not support eSIM | Local SIM if unlocked; pocket Wi-Fi if locked |
Group that stays together, or Wi-Fi-only devices | Pocket Wi-Fi, possibly alongside eSIMs |
Everyone needs their own connection when apart | One plan per phone (eSIM or local SIM) |
If a travel eSIM fits, check whether your phone supports eSIM, then compare Japan eSIM plans or plans for your destination.

